I really wasn't feeling well today, woke up all stuffy with a sore throat, so I decided that a day on the couch with a book was in order.
At first glance, The Truth About the Devlins reads like your standard rich-people drama: wealthy family, lots of power, zero communication skills, and enough dysfunction to fuel a year’s worth of therapy bills. The Devlins are a high-powered family of lawyers—think sharks in suits—with a black sheep brother, TJ, who’s doing his best just to stay sober and out of trouble. Naturally, they treat him like a ticking time bomb. Every time the man so much as sneezes, someone accuses him of falling off the wagon. It's exhausting.
Then big brother John drops a bombshell: he might’ve killed someone and wants TJ’s help. And when the situation gets messy, guess who gets thrown under the bus? That’s right—TJ. Because if you can’t trust family to betray you for their own gain, who can you trust?
Despite this rocky start, the family’s arc is surprisingly redemptive. Lisa Scottoline does a solid job of peeling back the layers to show that even cold, sharp-suited people in McMansions can find their way back to what actually matters: family, not just the money or the cover-ups.
The heart of this story is TJ, and honestly, he’s the reason I was so invested. He’s a recovering alcoholic and ex-con, struggling to rebuild his life while surrounded by people who treat him like a walking relapse. His story hit hard. I’ve known people in similar battles, and Scottoline captures that lonely, uphill fight with a lot of empathy. When TJ relapsed, I just wanted to jump into the book, sit beside him at Jesse’s grave, and remind him he wasn’t alone.
And then there’s John. Oh, John. He had everyone fooled. The golden boy turns out to be deeply flawed, and watching TJ slowly unravel the truth was so satisfying. John’s descent from beloved son to walking house of cards was one of the book’s most surprising turns.
Thematically, the book dives deep into the tension between family loyalty and personal integrity. At first, the Devlins choose loyalty—but the twisted, code-of-silence kind that leads to coverups and consequences. Gabby, TJ’s sister, is the one who reminds everyone that integrity matters more. When she admits she turned John in to the FBI? Finally. Someone doing the right thing for the right reasons.
Pacing-wise, this book was a ride. It hooked me on page one and never let go. I read it in a single sitting—because how do you put down a book that opens with, “Hey, I think I might’ve killed someone”?
As for the legal drama, it’s there, but it doesn’t swamp the story. It raises the stakes and gives weight to the personal conflicts without turning into a courtroom procedural. Perfect balance.
Trope-wise, this book hit a few sweet spots on my tracker:
-
Everyone Has Secrets (so. many. secrets.)
-
Strong, Lone Wolf with a Past (hello, TJ)
-
Powerful People Doing Terrible Things (John really carried this one)
In short: if you like crime thrillers with heart, family dysfunction, personal redemption, and a main character you’ll want to root for with your whole soul, The Truth About the Devlins should be at the top of your list. I’m giving it 5 out of 5 stars and would definitely recommend it to anyone who enjoys mysteries with emotional depth and flawed, unforgettable characters.