Even Lucy doesn't know if she can trust Lucy.
For September's book, the Rusty Book Club chose Listen for the Lie by Amy Tintera. I should have waited. At least until September 1st. I had things to do today.
None of them got done. Instead, I picked it up and apparently decided that laundry, housework, errands, and anything else remotely productive could wait until I figured out whether Lucy Chase murdered her best friend.
Here's the scoop:
Years ago, Lucy was found wandering along a Texas road, covered in her best friend Savvy's blood, with absolutely no memory of what happened. Savvy was dead. Lucy couldn't explain why. There wasn't enough evidence to charge her, but that didn't stop pretty much everyone in town from deciding she was guilty.
And really. Amnesia? How ... convenient.
The problem is that Lucy doesn't know whether she did it either. She's reluctantly back in her hometown for her grandmother's birthday party, where a popular true-crime podcaster has decided to investigate Savvy's murder. Yeah. Grandma set her up.
As he starts interviewing the people who were there, old stories begin to shift, secrets start crawling out of the woodwork, and Lucy has to confront the possibility that somewhere inside her missing memories is the answer to what happened that night.
I loved Lucy. Absolutely loved her. This woman majors in snark and speaks sarcasm as a second language. She's been accused of murdering her best friend, nearly everyone in town thinks she did it, and even she can't say with absolute certainty that they're wrong. Rather than turn her into a weepy, helpless protagonist, Tintera gives Lucy a wonderfully dark sense of humor and a sharp tongue.
My kind of gal.
The podcast structure works beautifully alongside Lucy's narration. As the podcaster interviews people connected to Savvy and the night she died, we're hearing their versions of events while Lucy is trying to piece together her own. It adds another layer to the mystery because nobody's account can simply be accepted as fact—including Lucy's. She isn't deliberately hiding the truth from us. She genuinely doesn't know what the truth is.
Neither did I. I had theories, though. Isn't it always the boyfriend or husband? And when said man is apparently willing to screw anything that moves, surely we've found ourselves a prime candidate.
Think again. I was completely blindsided.
That's exactly what I want from a thriller. Give me characters I want to follow, make me suspicious of everybody, let me confidently construct my little theories ... and then prove me completely wrong. And if you can make me abandon everything I planned to accomplish that day because I absolutely have to know what happened?
Five stars.
The dust bunnies will still be there tomorrow.




















