Fake dating, handwritten letters, and no dead bodies. Somehow, I was still up until 3 a.m.
I picked up Yours Truly because I needed a break from murder and mayhem. I wanted something light, cute, and cuddly that didn't require me to keep track of bodies, suspects, motives, or who had buried whom in the backyard. I did not expect fake dating, good old-fashioned handwritten letters, and two ridiculously likable people to keep me reading until 3 a.m. Apparently, romance can be dangerous to my sleep schedule, too.
Jacob Maddox is an ER doctor with severe anxiety. Interestingly enough, the emergency room is one of the places where he is most comfortable. Give the man a medical crisis and he's fine. Give him an awkward social interaction and things can go spectacularly sideways.
Enter Briana Ortiz, an ER nurse and well-loved team leader who is up for a promotion. Briana is smart, confident, fiercely protective of her people, and possesses an almost sixth sense for figuring out what someone needs. Unfortunately, that sixth sense fails her completely when it comes to Jacob.
Briana decides Jacob is one of those doctors: the arrogant, I'm-better-than-you variety. She's not particularly shy about letting him know she doesn't care for him. Then she accidentally breaks his phone after crashing into him in the hallway, and Jacob's anxiety makes explaining what happened approximately 4,000 times messier than it needed to be.
So he writes her a letter. An actual letter. On paper. With a pen. In an envelope.
Be still my old-school heart.
That first letter changes everything. Briana realizes she has completely misjudged Jacob, and the two begin exchanging handwritten letters. In a world of texts, DMs, dating apps, and messages consisting entirely of emojis, there was something ridiculously charming about watching two people sit down and actually write to each other. More importantly, the letters give Jacob a way to communicate without the immediate pressures created by his anxiety, and they give Briana the opportunity to see the thoughtful, funny, compassionate man she couldn't see through his awkwardness.
Of course, this is a romance novel, so we need complications. Jacob needs a date to his brother's wedding. His brother, incidentally, is marrying Jacob's ex-girlfriend.
Oh, sure. Why not? Even in cute, cuddly romance novels, some people can be really weaselly.
Briana agrees to be his fake girlfriend, and the more time they spend together, the less fake their relationship starts to feel. Unfortunately, the original arrangement gives both of them a perfectly reasonable excuse to doubt everything happening between them. Is that touch real or part of the act? Did that moment mean something, or are they just putting on a convincing show?
Normally, this is about where I'd start yelling, “Communication, people!” But Jimenez gives both characters legitimate reasons for their uncertainty.
Briana is still dealing with the emotional fallout from an ugly divorce and an ex-husband who left some pretty deep scars behind. Trust doesn't come easily anymore. Meanwhile, her younger brother Benny desperately needs a kidney transplant, and Jacob becomes his donor. That creates another question Briana can't quite silence: Does Jacob really want to be with her, or does he feel obligated to stay because he gave Benny a kidney and became connected to their family?
Jacob has his own doubts, and his anxiety makes emotional risk particularly difficult. Does Briana really want to stay with him, or does she feel like she owes him because he gave her brother a kidney?
What I loved about Jacob, though, is that Jimenez never presents Briana as the magical woman who “fixes” him. Jacob has sought therapy and treatment. He understands his anxiety, knows his boundaries, and has built a successful life while learning how to manage it. He doesn't need Briana to cure him. He just needs someone willing to understand him.
And Briana does.
That's ultimately what made these two work so well for me. Briana instinctively understands what other people need, while Jacob has worked hard to understand what he needs. Both are caregivers. Both are compassionate. Both carry some emotional baggage. And underneath all the fake dating and romantic confusion, they genuinely like each other.
Yes, there are a couple of steamy scenes. Anyone who has read my reviews for more than five minutes knows those aren't my thing, so I exercised my highly developed page-skipping skills and carried on. I can't really fault a romance novel for containing romance-novel things.
I went into Yours Truly looking for a palate cleanser, something sweet and entertaining before I returned to my regularly scheduled murder and mayhem. Instead, I became completely invested in Jacob, Briana, Benny, those wonderful handwritten letters, and whether two very good people could finally convince themselves that the other one really did love them.
Using my own rating system, there's no question about this one.
★★★★★ — Five stars. I was still reading at 3 a.m. Bedtime never stood a chance.
Well played, Abby Jimenez. Apparently you don't need a dead body to keep me turning pages. And by the way, I'm absolutely stealing the glitter payback idea. That was genius.





















