I just finished 4th of July by James Patterson, and let me tell you, Lindsay Boxer really needed a break. After getting shot and then sued, you’d think she’d take some time to unwind — but nope. She can’t help herself. I get it; I’m the same way. Even when I’m off for the summer and not teaching, I’m still thinking about lesson plans. The mental switch just never flips off.
The central crime in this book was wild: a serial killer (or so you think) who kills people and then whips them? I mean… that was new for me. And then when it turns out there are actually three killers, all with their own messed-up justifications? Wow. Sometimes people seriously scare me.
The courtroom drama really amped up the tension for me. As a former legal secretary, I know firsthand that you can never predict what a jury will do. When the jury in Lindsay’s trial asked if they could limit the dollar amount to be awarded, my heart just sank. And yes, lawyers like that defense attorney? They’re out there. As egocentric and full of themselves as ever.
One subplot that really stood out was Keith, the auto mechanic. I liked that guy! And then — bam — plot twist: he’s one of the killers. Why, Keith, WHY? Why would you flirt with a cop if you’re out committing serial murders? That’s some next-level dumb.
The setting, Half Moon Bay, gave the story such a perfect contrast. It’s this peaceful little town where you’d never expect bad things to happen — and yet here come brutal murders shaking everything up. It’s the kind of backdrop that makes the crimes feel even more jarring.
Pacing-wise, the book hit the sweet spot. I was completely hooked but could still set it down long enough to get some sleep — and then eagerly pick it back up again the next morning. Patterson and Paetro know how to keep you on the line without making you feel like you’re sprinting breathless through the pages.
And let’s talk about those twists. First, Keith (still shaking my head), then Carolee — the sweet baking lady?! She’s showing up with cakes and planning to skin people alive? Total whiplash. And Bob the lawyer? Buddy, what were you thinking? I didn’t see any of those reveals coming, which is exactly how I like my thrillers.
Lindsay’s personal struggles were another highlight. The weight of the trial, the nightmares, the pull to get back to work, the joy of making new friends, and then the crushing disappointment when those friendships collapse — it all felt authentic. Also, I really appreciate how her romance is written. Just enough detail to get the point across without heading into “too much information” territory. That’s one reason I don’t usually read pure romance novels — I don’t need to know everything, thanks!
By the end, I was left wanting more — in the best way. I’m thrilled that the trial worked out for Lindsay and the killers were caught, but now I’m eager to see how Yuri’s character develops in future books. I liked Jill, and I’m curious whether Yuri will slide into that same role of friend and ally.
Honestly, I’d recommend this book to pretty much anyone: fans of crime thrillers, psychological thrillers, light romance, even horror readers. It’s got a little something for everyone.
One last thought — I noticed that 2nd Chance and 3rd Degree were written with Andrew Gross, while 4th of July was co-written with Maxine Paetro. I definitely enjoyed this one more than the first three. Coincidence? Maybe. But who better to help write about a Women’s Murder Club than another woman? It’s possible the shift in co-author style made a difference I didn’t consciously pick up on — but my brain definitely appreciated it.
Five out of five stars from me — because any book that can keep me up past bedtime, make me yell “Keith, you idiot!” out loud, and remind me why I’m glad I left the legal world behind deserves all the gold stars. Patterson and Paetro, you’ve earned yourself a fan — now excuse me while I go lock my doors and double-check the baking lady next time she shows up with cupcakes.